DNA from underwater archaeological sites

Lay summary authored by Lisa Briggs. Read the full paper here: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.71

The methods used to study ancient DNA have progressed rapidly over the last few decades. As more submerged archaeological sites are discovered and explored, it is possible to apply these new methods and technological advancements in DNA research to recently discovered archaeological material from maritime and underwater sites. Environmental DNA, in particular, has been shown to be particularly important in characterising the human activities that might have taken place at ancient sites, both on land and under the sea. Given these developments, and the heightened awareness of how important it is to characterise the environmental samples taken from archaeological sites, it is necessary to reconsider previously published studies conducted on archaeological material from submerged sites.

Briggs_agamask_qar

Underwater archaeologist Lisa Briggs recovering artefacts from the Queen Anne’s Revenge shipwreck (Photo credit: W. Welsh)

This paper explores the pitfalls, promise and future directions of ancient DNA research on archaeological material recovered from submerged sites. First, a selection of previously published studies is assessed in light of the new methods and technological advancements that have now been made available to archaeological scientists. Past research conducted on human and animal bones, waterlogged plant remains, and archaeological ceramics is considered. Finding ways to authenticate the DNA recovered as ancient is of paramount importance. Next, the promise that DNA analysis holds for artefacts and environmental samples recovered from underwater sites is explored. Submerged prehistoric settlement sites, ancient shipwrecks, and harbour sites hold particular promise for the application of new methods designed to maximise the recovery of ancient DNA. Finally, the future directions of ancient DNA research on archaeological material from underwater sites are considered. Understanding what DNA is naturally present in the seafloor sediment that accumulates over archaeological sites, what DNA is naturally present in seawater, and how DNA breaks down in the marine environment will greatly enhance our ability to assign an archaeological meaning to DNA discovered on ancient underwater sites.

Full paper: Briggs, L., 2020. Ancient DNA Research in Maritime and Underwater Archaeology: Pitfalls, Promise, and Future Directions. Open Quaternary, 6(1), p.3. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.71

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Identifying the Greatest Earthquakes of the Past 2000 Years at the Nehalem River Estuary, Northern Oregon Coast, USA

Lay summary authored by Alan Nelson. Read the full paper here: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.70

Will the next great earthquake at the Cascadia subduction zone, whose fault dips beneath the coasts of British Columbia, Washington, Oregon, and northern California, be a giant (magnitude 9) like the earthquake and tsunami that killed thousands in Japan in 2011, or the similar Cascadia earthquake in AD 1700? How often do such great earthquakes and their accompanying high tsunamis strike this region? To answer these questions geologists study past great earthquakes beneath coastal wetlands where evidence of them is best preserved.

Nelson 1

Part of the field crew describing earthquake stratigraphy in cores, and taking their GPS locations, in Botts marsh, near the mouth of the Nehalem River, northern Oregon, in July 2009 (Photo: A. Nelson).

Longer fault ruptures produce larger earthquakes, so much effort has gone into determining the length of the Cascadia fault that ruptured during each great earthquake of the past few thousands of years. Usually this has been attempted by radiocarbon dating coastal wetland sediment that records sudden subsidence during earthquakes or their accompanying tsunamis at a series of sites along the coast. But the errors on radiocarbon dating are still too large to distinguish between one giant earthquake rupturing 500-1200 km along the coast, or a series of merely great earthquakes over a few years to a few decades progressively rupturing shorter sections of coast.

At the Nehalem River estuary of northern Oregon we used a more direct method of estimating the magnitude of prehistoric subduction-zone earthquakes—by reconstructing the amount that the coast suddenly dropped down during each great earthquake. The most precise way to measure this sudden subsidence is to study changes in fossil microscopic tidal plants (diatoms) and animals (foraminifera) in tidal sediment at each wetland over thousands of years. Beneath the Nehalem wetlands we identified changes in sediment that suggested three times when the coast suddenly dropped down. Using new statistical methods, combined with information recently gathered by others about how high above low tide modern diatoms and foraminifera typically live, we measured 0.6-1.7 m, 0.3-1.5 m, and 0.6-1.5 m of subsidence during the three earthquakes. Study of fossil diatoms independently confirms similar amounts of subsidence during the two younger earthquakes. Our radiocarbon ages show that the earthquakes occurred about 320, 900, and 1500 years ago.

Nelson 2

Rob Witter (USGS) measures the depths of the upper stratigraphic contacts of two subsided marsh soils, contact A (at 1.1 m on the measuring tape, below his left hand) and contact B (at 0.18 m on the measuring tape, between his knee and ankle), at an outcrop near the mouth of the Nehalem River, northern Oregon, in June 2009. Contact A formed through sudden subsidence of the marsh during the great Cascadia earthquake of 1700 CE. Contact B formed during an earlier great earthquake about 1200-1000 years ago (Photo: A. Nelson).

Although no one can predict the magnitude or time of a future great earthquake, by learning more about past subduction-zone earthquakes, and how their fault ruptures may have varied along the coast, seismologists and geologists hope to forecast the probability and magnitude of a future great earthquake at Cascadia.

Full paper: Nelson, A.R., Hawkes, A.D., Sawai, Y., Engelhart, S.E., Witter, R., Grant-Walter, W.C., Bradley, L.-A., Dura, T., Cahill, N. and Horton, B., 2020. Identifying the Greatest Earthquakes of the Past 2000 Years at the Nehalem River Estuary, Northern Oregon Coast, USA. Open Quaternary, 6(1), p.2. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.70

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Rock-boring organisms tell us about sea-level fluctuations in a warmer world

Lay summary authored by Michaela Falkenroth. Find the full paper here: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.72

The Last Interglacial, 130.000 until 115.000 years ago, was the last time global mean temperatures and global sea-level were higher than today. This has put the period onto the agenda of scientists, who are asked to provide communities with scenarios of coastal evolution in a warming world. Researchers currently conduct a global database of areas, where remains of last interglacial shorelines still present today.

One of these areas is the coastline of Oman, that borders the western Indian Ocean. While the Sultanate`s coastlines are for the most part preserved in their natural state without any anthropogenic influence, a true rarity among the coastlines of the world, their sea-level history is still understudied.

Last Interglacial Paleoshoreline with notch (left) and beachrock (right) in Sur

Last Interglacial Paleoshoreline with notch (left) and beachrock (right) in Sur (Photo: M. Falkenroth).

With this work we wish to lay the ground for research on last interglacial shorelines in Oman. Our example is a very well preserved tidal notch at Sur Lagoon that is located 3.93 m above recent mean sea level. Tidal notches are carved into rocky shorelines by wave action and organisms that bore into hard substrates. These organisms can be clams, sponges or worms that create cavities in a rock-surface by chemical dissolution and mechanical action. The cavities function as shelter for the animal or are a side effect of its feeding behaviour.

A tidal notch is an indicator for sea-level as its deepest point lies at mean sea-level while its floor and roof represent the tidal range. Because the process of notch-formation is rather slow, they form in periods during which sea-level remained stable. This also means that the notch itself will not significantly change if mean sea-level rises or falls for a short period of time.

Rocksurface with Lithiphaga borings

Rocksurface with Lithiphaga borings (Photo: M. Falkenroth).

The organisms living within the notch however, will change their behaviour almost instantaneously, as their habitat is restricted to a certain bathymetry. The common boring clam Lithophaga needs to be permanently submerged. When sea-level falls, Lithophaga will abandon all newly exposed surfaces and if sea-level rises the clams will penetrate the newly submerged rocksurface within a couple of years.

This can lead to a mismatch between the shape of a tidal notch and the distribution of organisms within it, as they act on different timescales. The tidal notch in Sur shows Lithophaga borings above the notch roof, which are interpreted as remains of a short term sea-level rise subsequent to notch-formation and tell a story of last interglacial sea-level variability.

Full paper: Falkenroth, M., Adolphs, S., Cahnbley, M., Bagci, H., Kázmér, M., Mechernich, S. and Hoffmann, G., 2020. Biological Indicators Reveal Small-Scale Sea-Level Variability During MIS 5e (Sur, Sultanate of Oman). Open Quaternary, 6(1), p.1. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.72

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

“Animals and people in the Netherlands’ past”: >50 years of archaeozoology in the Netherlands

Lay summary authored by Canan Çakırlar and Youri van den Hurk. Read the full paper here: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.61

It has been more than 50 years since the late Prof. Anneke T. Clason published her PhD thesis, Animal and Man in Holland’s Past (Clason 1967), based on animal bone remains excavated at sites in the Province of Holland in the Netherlands. Subsequently, Clason became the leading archaeozoologists (also called a zooarchaeologist – a specialist expert who analyses animal remains from archaeological sites) in the Netherlands, as well as its international face. Since the late 1960’s, her colleagues and students have built a strong tradition of archaeozoology in the Netherlands, producing, interpreting and publishing an enormous amount of data.

However, most archaeozoological data remain difficult to access and/or are scattered in grey literature in Dutch. Syntheses are scarce. The scarcity of overviews hinders efforts to train, strategize, and internationalize this field of study in the Netherlands. Inspired by the 50th anniversary of Clason’s career launch, we wrote this review article to provide an accessible introduction for beginners in and outsiders to Dutch archaeozoology.

Extinctions and introductions Netherlands aa

Figure 1: Overview of introductions and extinctions of some mammal and bird species in the Netherlands during the Holocene. BC and AD dates are calendar years (calibrated dates).

As part of this synthesis, we discuss twelve themes that have received the most attention from Dutch archaeozoologists and their predecessors over the past 50 years, bringing together a thorough and extensive overview of the archaeozoology of the Netherlands from the Palaeolithic to the Middle Ages. The themes vary from regional (e.g. archaeozoology of terps (artificial dwelling mounds in the northern part of the Netherlands)) to chronological (e.g. archaeozoology of the Bronze and Iron Ages) to overarching overviews (e.g. extinctions and invasions; see figure 1).

Each thematic section draws data from the most thoroughly studied (e.g. medieval site of Dorestad), interesting and/or best-known sites and assemblages (e.g. Swifterbant culture sites), and offers suggestions for future research directions (e.g. the beginnings of animal domestication and breed improvement). We display the wealth of archaeozoological information, the impact it can have on our understanding of human-animal interactions in the past, and how we can use this data to inform conservation.

References
Clason, A. 1967. Animal and man in Holland’s past: an investigation of the animal world surrounding man in prehistoric and early historic times in the provinces of North and South Holland. Unpublished thesis (PhD), Rijksuniversiteit Groningen.

The full paper in Open Quaternary: Çakirlar, C., van den Hurk, Y., van der Jagt, I., van Amerongen, Y., Bakker, J., Breider, R., van Dijk, J., Esser, K., Groot, M., de Jong, T., Kootker, L., Steenhuisen, F., Zeiler, J., van Kolfschoten, T., Prummel, W. and Lauwerier, R., 2019. Animals and People in the Netherlands’ Past: >50 Years of Archaeozoology in the Netherlands. Open Quaternary, 5(1), p.13. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.61

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

A multi-proxy reconstruction of environmental change in the vicinity of the North Bay outlet of pro-glacial Lake Algonquin

Lay summary authored by Ryan Rabett. Read the full article at: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.54

At the end of the last Ice Age large frigid lakes formed in the Great Lakes region of North America in front of the retreating Laurentide ice‐sheet. Subject to the effects of periodic meltwater surges through the lake system and by the rebound of the land itself once the great weight of the ice had gone, these lakes underwent repeated changes in shape, depth and drainage over comparatively short periods (with individual phases tending to last hundreds rather than thousands of years). Despite such changeable conditions the archaeological evidence that survives from this time suggests that their shorelines and the surrounding environment were capable of sustaining forays by Late Palaeoindian groups venturing into this new landscape from further to the south, though information is scant.

Balsam Creek kettle lake basin

Balsam Creek kettle lake basin (Photo: R. Rabett).

For this project we aimed to produce a new environmental record for northeast Ontario, an area that featured centrally in the late drainage history of one such lake: Lake Algonquin. At its height, 13‐11,000 years ago, Algonquin was the largest lake in the Great Lakes Basin, filling the area of today’s Huron and Michigan Great Lakes as well as a swathe of adjacent lands. Following reconnaissance by the senior project author (PK), we extracted and analysed a core from a small lake in a suitable location c. 34 km north‐east of the city of North Bay, Ontario near the hamlet of Balsam Creek.

Coring in the Balsam Creek kettle lake

Coring in the Balsam Creek kettle lake (Photo: T. Rabett).

The environmental history preserved in the bed of the lake begins c. 10,500 years ago, following one of the final phases in Algonquin’s late evolution, and when the local landscape had become only recently ice‐free. From there on the core extends through time up to the last few hundred years. Among our results we identified two early intervals when deteriorating climate conditions significantly affected vegetation around the lake. Interestingly, both coincided with peaks in volcanic ash (attributed to eruptions in Oregon) also identified in the core, suggesting a possible association. Outside of these times, however, the character of the local forest did not change significantly, indicating that this and other small similarly enclosed lake basins may have been less susceptible to resource disturbance affecting the wider landscape. Given the scarcity of well‐preserved Late Palaeoindian sites in this part of Ontario, such locales could represent a profitable focus for future archaeological investigation of the first human pioneers to enter the Northlands.

Trekking to the Balsam Creek kettle lake

Trekking to the Balsam Creek kettle lake (Photo: T. Rabett).

Rabett, R.J., Pryor, A.J.E., Simpson, D.J., Farr, L.R., Pyne-O’Donnell, S., Blaauw, M., Crowhurst, S., Mulligan, R.P.M., Hunt, C.O., Stevens, R., Fiacconi, M., Beresford-Jones, D. and Karrow, P.F., 2019. A Multi-Proxy Reconstruction of Environmental Change in the Vicinity of the North Bay Outlet of Pro-Glacial Lake Algonquin. Open Quaternary, 5(1), p.12. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.54

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Reconstructing the Diets of Past Arctic Peoples: A Review

Lay summary authored by Alison Harris and Deirdre Elliott. Read the full paper here: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.67

In the popular imagination, the Arctic often presents as a great white expanse of ice, snow and rock, however, it encompasses river deltas, deep fjords, shallow basins, polynyas and tundra, and these regions offer a variety of resources, such as migrating seals and whales, walrus, fish and seabirds, berries and fresh green plants, that can be hunted and gathered at different times of the year. Early communities in the Arctic successfully used skin boats, dog teams and specialized tools made from bone, baleen, caribou antler, and walrus ivory to hunt marine mammals and make homes for themselves from the coast of Alaska to Greenland.

Stable isotope analysis is a method used to study the diets of ancient humans and animals. Bones and teeth are composed of chemical elements sourced from food, and by measuring isotopes of these elements in the bones, teeth, or hair of archaeological human skeletons, it is possible to reconstruct the average diet of a person during life. In our paper, we review the stable isotope studies that have been conducted on the skeletal remains of Inuit and Yupik people from the Arctic, dating from ~AD 1000 to AD 1800. Drawing from this body of literature, we suggest several additional considerations that may enrich interpretations of stable isotope data from Inuit and Yupik skeletons: the interaction between human physiology and the high fat and high protein diets of the Inuit; the influence of traditional food preparation methods on food chemistry; and the importance of generating and interpreting these data in a way that incorporates the priorities and concerns of indigenous stakeholders.

In the Circumpolar North, the impacts of climate change are severe and the role of archaeology in mediating this threat is limited, but not insignificant. With a greater understanding of arctic life in the past, we gain the ability to imbue strategies for protecting northern communities with greater cultural sensitivity and respect for traditional ways of life.

Harris, A.J.T. and Elliott, D.A., 2019. Stable Isotope Studies of North American Arctic Populations: A Review. Open Quaternary, 5(1), p.11. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.67

Part of the Special Collection: Methodological Advances in Coastal and Maritime Archaeology.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Working from the Known to the Unknown: Linking the Subaerial Archaeology and the Submerged Landscapes of Santarosae Island, Alta California, USA

Lay summary authored by Todd Braje. Read the full paper here:

http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.66

Just 30 years ago, every classroom textbook, scientific presentation, and documentary film told the same story of the Peopling of the New World. The First Americans were terrestrial big game hunters, who followed migrating herds of mammoths and mastodons across the Bering Land Bridge and down the Ice-Free Corridor into the North American heartland. These Clovis hunters used deadly and distinctive projectile point technology to successfully hunt big game and spread from sea to shining sea beginning about 13,500 years ago. Despite some scientific opposition, this story seemed to fit available archaeological, genetic, and paleoenvironmental data.

oq-5-66-g5.png

The Northern Channel Islands geophysical survey study area with the locations of our regional track lines and the four 1 km2 detailed survey box locations. Figure taken from the paper.

This all changed in the 1990s with the discovery and dating of the Monte Verde II site in southern Chile, occupied by humans a thousand years prior to the arrival of Clovis and the cultural complex that was once believed to represent the First Americans. A variety of new archaeological discoveries and genetic and paleoecological data now suggest the First Americans might have arrived in boats, following New World Pacific coastlines. Rigorous scientific testing of this hypothesis has been difficult due to the flooding of paleocoastlines by rising sea levels as global ice turned to water and melted into our world’s oceans after the Last Glacial Maximum about 20,000 years ago. The shorelines these early migrants would have followed are now, for the most part, underwater. Here, we describe efforts to locate where submerged archaeological sites might be found in southern California, along the paleoshorelines of the Northern Channel Islands. These islands contain the highest concentration of Paleocoastal sites in all of the Americas and may be key to helping us uncover evidence of the First Americans. We developed a predictive model to refine massive search areas and offshore geophysical mapping and coring to test high probability areas for evidence of submerged archaeological sites.

Full paper:

Braje, T.J., Maloney, J.M., Gusick, A.E., Erlandson, J.M., Nyers, A., Davis, L., Gill, K.M., Reeder-Myers, L. and Ball, D., 2019. Working from the Known to the Unknown: Linking the Subaerial Archaeology and the Submerged Landscapes of Santarosae Island, Alta California, USA. Open Quaternary, 5(1), p.10. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/oq.66

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment